Russia in new blow to ICC as court urges nations ‘Don’t go’
Russia dealt the International Criminal Court a fresh blow Wednesday as the court's top officials urged nations to support the tribunal hit by a wave of unprecedented defections.
Moscow has never ratified the world’s only permanent war crimes court, but in a heavily symbolic move on the opening day of the ICC’s annual meeting, it said it was formally withdrawing its signature to the tribunal’s founding Rome Statute.
“The court did not live up to the hopes associated with it and did not become truly independent,” Russia’s foreign ministry said, describing its work as “one-sided and inefficient”.
The move came only days after The Gambia on Monday formally notified the United Nations it was leaving the ICC, following in the footsteps of South Africa and Burundi.
“Don’t go,” pleaded Senegalese minister Sidiki Kaba, the president of the ICC’s Assembly of State Parties as he opened an eight-day meeting.
“In a world criss-crossed by violent extremism… it is urgent and necessary to defend the ideal of justice for all.”
The tribunal opened its doors in 2002 in The Hague as a court of last resort to try the world’s worst crimes where national courts are unable or unwilling to act.
In his passionate plea, Kaba admitted the ICC was undergoing a “difficult moment”.
With Russia and China having blocked UN moves to refer war crimes in Syria to the ICC for investigation, Kaba acknowledged some believed international justice was marred by “double standards”.
But he offered reassurances, saying: “You have been heard.”
There have long been accusations of bias against African nations. And Kenya, Namibia and Uganda have also indicated they are considering pulling out of the Rome Statute.
– ‘Legal dilemma’ –
South Africa’s Justice Minister Michael Masutha told the assembly the decision to quit “was not taken lightly” by his country, which had played a major role in drawing up the founding statute.
He argued South Africa had been treated unfairly by the court when it did not arrest visiting Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir, even though the ICC has issued an international warrant for his arrest on war crimes charges.
Pretoria had found itself caught in a dilemma, with “conflicting obligations” to uphold both the ICC’s rules and international law granting immunity to heads of state, Masutha said, insisting his country “would not become a safe haven for fugitives.”
Chief prosecutor Fatou Bensouda insisted however that the withdrawals were not a “crisis” adding her office would continue “to forge ahead to deliver on its important mandate”.
“We must not and will not allow that law falls silent during wars and conflicts,” she insisted.
“Without the ICC we will regress into an even more turbulent world where chaos and violence take the upper hand.”
On the eve of the meeting, Bensouda, who has already opened preliminary probes into cases in the Palestinian territories, Colombia and Ukraine, revealed she may be poised to launch her most complex investigation so far.
In her annual report she said there was a “reasonable basis” to believe US troops as well as the Taliban and Afghan forces may have committed war crimes in Afghanistan.
– ‘Do not betray victims’ –
If a full-blown investigation goes ahead, the tribunal would be taking on its most politically controversial investigation to date exposing US forces for the first time to an ICC investigation.
Palestinian foreign minister Riad Malik meanwhile pressed the court to launch a full investigation into what he said where “crimes that continue to be committed by Israeli occupation.”
To drop the probe “would send a message to our children .. that criminals can get away with their crimes, because we live in a world where might is right.”
UN human rights chief Zeid Ra’ad Al Hussein insisted “there is no substitute for the ICC” and in the long-term, “these states will boomerang back as the court is accepted by more and more states”.
Warning that “a new trend of isolationist and unprincipled leadership” was sweeping the world, Zeid said: “Now is not the time to abandon the post. This is the time of resolve and strength.”
“Do not betray the victims, nor your own people. Stand by the Rome Statute and the court.”
Currently nine out of the 10 full ICC investigations are in African countries. The other is in Georgia.