topics
tools
Expatica countries
Index Last Var.(%)
BEL 20 2117.66 -0.08
DAX 6323.19 -0.26
IBEX 30 6401.2 -2.17
CAC 40 3042.97 -0.16
FTSE 100 5356.34 0.09
AEX 292.76 0.00
DJIA 12454.83 -0.60
Nasdaq 2837.53 -0.07
FTSE MIB 13057.26 -0.74
TSX Composite 11539.51 -0.32
ASX 4120.2 0.96
Hang seng 18800.99 0.47
Straits Times 2787.22 0.52
ISEQ 20 501.76 0.16
You are here: Home News Community News French draft bill to fine burqa-wearing women
Enlarge font Decrease font Text size


08/01/2010French draft bill to fine burqa-wearing women

The leader of the governing UMP party in the National Assembly is drafting up a bill that will fine Muslim women up to EUR 750 for wearing a burqa.

Paris – Muslim women who wear the full Islamic veil in France will face a possible EUR 750 fine, according to a draft bill unveiled Thursday by the leader of the parliamentary majority.

Jean-Francois Cope, who heads the governing UMP party in the National Assembly, told Le Figaro newspaper's weekly magazine that men who force their wives to wear the burqa or niqab could face an even heavier fine.

"The law will address an issue of security," Cope said in an interview with the magazine.

"The proposed measure would prohibit the covering of the face in public places and on the streets, with the exception of special cultural events or carnivals."

The draft legislation will be presented in the next two weeks and should come up for debate in parliament after the March regional elections, he said.

The majority leader, who is also openly campaigning to succeed President Nicolas Sarkozy as the right-wing candidate for the presidency in 2017, said the burqa must be banned to defend women's rights.

"We can measure the modernity of a society by the way it treats and respects women," he said.

France's political establishment is divided on whether to ban the burqa, with the opposition Socialists this week saying that it opposed a law even though Muslim women must be discouraged from wearing the full veil.

The burqa debate has heated up ahead of the release at the end of the month of a much-awaited report by a parliamentary panel that has conducted six months of hearings on the issue.

Many politicians from the left and right have cautioned that a draconian law banning the head-to-toe veil would be difficult to enforce and probably face a challenge in the European rights court.

Sarkozy himself has said that the burqa is not welcome in France but has not stated publicly whether legislation should be enacted.

Critics argue that a specific law enacted to ban the full veil would be tantamount to using a sledgehammer to swat a fly. Only 1,900 women wear the full veil in France, according to the interior ministry.

In the interview, Cope argued that a law would act as a deterrent by sending a "clear message" that France will not allow women to fully cover themselves.

AFP / Expatica


4 reactions to this article

Sara posted: 2010-01-08 14:29:02

whilst I do not condone the forced wearing of the burka I think women should have the choice if they wish to wear it. It is patrinising to asume that they can not choose for themselves. I am a feminist and not religous but believe in free speech and to wear what one wishes whether it is a mini skirt or to be coverred up

steve posted: 2010-01-09 14:29:58

In most cases they cannot choose for themselves. Because they are severely dealt with if they flout the 'code' (more nonsense invented by insecure men) they have little choice. How has that got anything to do with free speech? As for it being patronising to assume that many of these women have any choices at all in some areas..... words fail me. Have you any idea what happens to them if they disobey?????
I still wonder that it might not be somewhat over-the-top to ban the covering of faces - what happens if you want to wear a balaclava in cold weather?

Sara posted: 2010-01-10 22:11:28

Hi Steve, I said I certainly do not condone the forced covering up of women. I worked for the medical foundation for victims of torture , women's' aid , and with refugees in the past I have also lived in the Middle East. I have helped women fleeing from persecution and violence. I di however come across - strange as it may seem to you - who did wish to cover themselves. I just think that it a very high handed and arrogant approach to a sensitive subject. The best way is through education and tolerance is it not?

steve posted: 2010-01-11 12:24:02

Sara
You have much experience in this area that I do not. However, it is also true that kidnap victims often become slavishly devoted to their captors and want nothing other than to please. Patty Hurst is perhaps the most well known.
The proposal is high-handed but do you really believe that our efforts to 'educate' will work when there are men of violence keeping these women down? I'm afraid I don't - and I would normally be the biggest advocate of using education to prevail. As for tolerance, is this for the oppressed females or the oppressing males? It is tolerance - some would say apathy - that permitted the rise of Hitler and his henchmen. In that case Churchill was one of only a few souls who saw that tolerance was anything but the right answer. Of course that is an extreme example but if forcing women to cover themselves for deeply dubious reasons was allowed to progress unchecked, might it not one day be forced on all our children? A tiny acorn does grow into a huge tree - it takes years but it does happen.

4 reactions to this article

Sara posted: 2010-01-08 14:29:02

whilst I do not condone the forced wearing of the burka I think women should have the choice if they wish to wear it. It is patrinising to asume that they can not choose for themselves. I am a feminist and not religous but believe in free speech and to wear what one wishes whether it is a mini skirt or to be coverred up

steve posted: 2010-01-09 14:29:58

In most cases they cannot choose for themselves. Because they are severely dealt with if they flout the 'code' (more nonsense invented by insecure men) they have little choice. How has that got anything to do with free speech? As for it being patronising to assume that many of these women have any choices at all in some areas..... words fail me. Have you any idea what happens to them if they disobey?????
I still wonder that it might not be somewhat over-the-top to ban the covering of faces - what happens if you want to wear a balaclava in cold weather?

Sara posted: 2010-01-10 22:11:28

Hi Steve, I said I certainly do not condone the forced covering up of women. I worked for the medical foundation for victims of torture , women's' aid , and with refugees in the past I have also lived in the Middle East. I have helped women fleeing from persecution and violence. I di however come across - strange as it may seem to you - who did wish to cover themselves. I just think that it a very high handed and arrogant approach to a sensitive subject. The best way is through education and tolerance is it not?

steve posted: 2010-01-11 12:24:02

Sara
You have much experience in this area that I do not. However, it is also true that kidnap victims often become slavishly devoted to their captors and want nothing other than to please. Patty Hurst is perhaps the most well known.
The proposal is high-handed but do you really believe that our efforts to 'educate' will work when there are men of violence keeping these women down? I'm afraid I don't - and I would normally be the biggest advocate of using education to prevail. As for tolerance, is this for the oppressed females or the oppressing males? It is tolerance - some would say apathy - that permitted the rise of Hitler and his henchmen. In that case Churchill was one of only a few souls who saw that tolerance was anything but the right answer. Of course that is an extreme example but if forcing women to cover themselves for deeply dubious reasons was allowed to progress unchecked, might it not one day be forced on all our children? A tiny acorn does grow into a huge tree - it takes years but it does happen.

Discussion Forums

Television in France

Buy fake passports, driver's licenses, identity cards

Eating & Drinking in France

Buy fake passports, driver's licenses, identity cards

Humour in France

Buy fake passports, driver's licenses, identity cards

Shopping in France

Buy fake passports, driver's licenses, identity cards

Films, Shows & Events in France

Buy fake passports, driver's licenses, identity cards

participate in the forums

Inside Expatica
Management culture in France

Management culture in France

This handy guide from Expertise in Labour Mobility includes information on business hierarchy, negotiations, and etiquette.

American associations and clubs in Paris

American associations and clubs in Paris

A listing of organizations in the Paris area that cater primarily to Americans living in France. Updated April 2011.

British associations and clubs in Paris

British associations and clubs in Paris

Our handy guide to the British community in Paris, from cricket clubs to Scottish country dancing lessons to where to find a jar of Marmite.

Anglophone services in France

Anglophone services in France

Here's a short introduction to our Banking section for those living in France, from how to open a bank account to Islamic banking and investments.