ExpatCH: Swiss socialism run amok!

ExpatCH: Swiss socialism run amok!

Comments3 comments

Bill Harby dissects the socialism of Swiss trash bags.

Hey all you patriotic American tea-bagger conservatives who see that our president is obviously a  "socialist" because he infringes on your right to get sick without healthcare -- you want a really scary example of socialism?

When I put out our little trash bag by the curb today, it cost us 2 francs (about $2.20). Two of the little grey plastic bags would have cost 4 francs. These bags are what Americans call "tall kitchen bags." With typical Swiss precision, here we call them 35-liter bags.

On January 1st, the beautiful and normally reasonable canton of Neuchâtel, where I live, put into effect a law requiring residents to put out their trash only in these expensive little grey plastic bags that had gone on sale shortly before.

American readers may be shocked at this obscene infringement upon personal freedom. How can local government (a Swiss canton is politically equivalent to a U.S. state) possibly dictate what kind of freakin' garbage bag we citizens use?

ExpatCH: Swiss socialism run amok!Until 2012, here in Neuchâtel we could stuff our trash into any old bag, but most of us bought the black plastic bags that seemed to be the only ones available in stores. They cost little enough so I never noticed, which is pretty remarkable here in Switzerland where the cost of nearly everything still occasionally makes me swoon.

The astronomical cost of our new trash bags here in Canton Neuchâtel is due to the best of all possible reasons. It is meant to protect the environment by encouraging people to recycle more and throw away less. And after one month, it would appear to be working. Trash volume has been cut nearly in half, according to local newspaper, L'Express. This in a country where recycling is already second nature, with recycling bins for glass, plastic and paper at grocery stores, train stops, crossroads, all over the place.

And yet, the normally law-abiding Swiss are not all on board with the expensive grey sac coup. L'Express reports that, since the law went into effect, one garbage bag in ten doesn't conform. These contraband bags are either the previously respectable, inexpensive black bags or worse, icky little plastic bags we put our mushrooms in at the grocery store. Obviously, this won't do. So the canton has hired workers to manually open and go through our non-conforming bags, looking for our address. Then they'll send us a warning letter, and if we persist in our anarchic ways, we can be fined.

We have learned our lesson. Now we'll only put our I.D. jetsam into a conforming grey bag. 

By Bill Harby.

Reprinted from ExpatCH.

Photo credit: jlz (head/hot photo), Qtea (photo 1)

Bill Harby is anBill Harby award-winning writer, editor and photographer based in Neuchâtel, Switzerland and Volcano, Hawai‘i. Yes, he loves chocolate and fondue, but raclette and Heidi make him nauseous.


Comment here on the article, or if you have a suggestion to improve this article, please click here.

If you believe any of the information on this page is incorrect or out-of-date, please let us know. Expatica makes every effort to ensure its articles are as comprehensive, accurate and up-to-date as possible, but we're also grateful for any help! (If you want to contact Expatica for any other reason, please follow the instructions on this website's contact page.)

Captcha Note: Characters are case sensitive
The details you provide on this page will not be used to send any unsolicited e-mail, and will not be sold to a third party. Privacy policy .

3 Comments To This Article

  • beth posted:

    on 10th November 2012, 11:00:18 - Reply

    Oops, just read Jeanne's comment above, so apparently at least some Vaud communes are doing this already. My French comprehension skills are advanced beginner at best ::-) Anyway, at least here along the shores of Lake Geneva, the Vaud communes have not yet implemented these bags...
  • beth posted:

    on 10th November 2012, 10:56:21 - Reply

    I read in LaCote that apparently there is a national law that, starting in 2012, requires all Swiss inhabitants to use these expensive garbage bags to encourage recycling and reduce waste. However, the cantons are charged with the implementation of this law, so many cantons are delaying the implementation as long as they can - Vaud being one of them. Apparently, they're not yet ready to open up all nonconforming bags to hunt down trash offenders!
  • Jeanne Hyler posted:

    on 10th November 2012, 05:42:55 - Reply

    My husband and I spend several months each year in the Canton of Vaud, Commune of Gryon. For the past several years, Gryon has required the use of "special" red garbage bags. Depending on the size, they average 2-3 Francs each. We've been told that it is another form of taxation, but I like your explanation better!
    BTW, raclette makes me nauseous, too!!