The Swiss nation generally loves foreigners – as long as they don’t infringe on Swiss culture, writes Mark Hay, who looks at the rising xenophobia spilling over into Swiss politics.
In the popular imagination, Switzerland is a land of fancy cheese and chocolates, alpine idylls, and chalets galore. A nation with a robust direct democracy, strong universal healthcare, and an uncannily potent economy, it’s a political model for many casual observers – there are literally posts on question forums like Quora asking whether Switzerland should be considered a functional utopia. Offering up a little nature, a little culture and a lot of comfort, it’s no wonder Switzerland’s a tourist darling, steadily siphoning off more American travellers every year.
Undercurrent of xenophobia in Switzerland
Yet below Switzerland’s shiny veneer, there’s an undercurrent of xenophobia that might make it a less than comfortable destination for at least one group of people: observant Muslims. Swiss Islamophobia predates the anti-migrant panic sweeping Europe today, and runs far deeper. And you’re probably equally likely to feel it as a Swiss Muslim or a just visitor.
The wider world first realised that something was rotten in the cantons of the Alps in 2009 when a fairly wide margin of the nation decided to ban the construction of Islamic minarets by popular referendum, arguing that they clashed with architectural tradition of the region. During the campaign on the referendum, the anti-immigrant conservative Swiss People’s Party (SVP) put up posters featuring a sinister woman in a black burqa standing before an image of Switzerland covered in black minarets (this was part of a series of troubling ads by the party featuring black representations of ‘outsiders’ being soundly rejected by the Swiss people).
The campaign reads ‘Sicherheit schaffen; mein Zuhause – unsere Schweiz’: ‘Establish safety; my home – our Switzerland’ (the pun is that ‘schaffen’ or ‘establish’ is similar to ‘Schaf’ or ‘sheep’).
The rise of anti-immigrant political parties in Switzerland
That same party swept national elections in 2015, taking a plurality of the vote and stealing seats from more progressive parties – all while running on an anti-immigrant platform.
In 2016, a local branch of the party in the Valais canton gathered enough signatures to force a law or referendum on a hijab ban. Another canton, Ticino, already approved a burqa ban in 2013 which went into effect in 2016, threatening fines between CHF 100–1,000, and rising to CHF 10,000 (around USD 10,000) for a second offence, for anyone (including visitors) caught wearing one. Similar bans have been floated in other cantons as well, while the SVP party is pushing for a nationwide ban.
But these bans aren’t just isolated and abstract statements of Swiss values.
Islamophobia in Switzerland
Muslims in the nation also talk about the visceral, felt experience of walking around wearing a hijab or some other visible symbol of their faith – non-Muslim Swiss seem to regard the hijab as an absolute symbol of women’s subjugation, rather than the choice it is for many. Their stories encompass everything from constant sideways glances to rejection by mentorship programs or job applications based on preconceptions about what it means to wear a hijab or to be observant.
To be fair to the Swiss, voter turnout for some of these rulings was miserable, press coverage of the Islamophobic campaigns was negative and courts took a dim view of the SVP’s campaign posters as well as of some headgear bans, so they’re not necessarily representative of the nation. But they slipped through — and the fact that people will mobilise for them while others stay at home or argue back from afar just shows how deep this xenophobioa runs for some.
Some Swiss may argue that they don’t actually have a problem with Islam. They say what they take issue with is the threat of any different community moving in, failing to integrate and, in the process, altering their culture and changing what it means to be Swiss – a situation they believe they have seen play out in many neighbouring nations to ill effect.
Immigration quotas in Switzerland
It’s the same logic behind more general immigration quotas enacted in Switzerland in recent years. But it’s also not really based on the Swiss experience of Islam; Switzerland’s 5 percent Muslim population is mostly made up of migrants or refugees from the 1990s Balkan conflicts who rarely ever wear the hijab or any other outward religious symbols. As for the minaret ban, the nation had only four minarets (which weren’t that visible) among their 150 or so mosques and prayer spaces at the time of the vote. In recent history, Switzerland’s also not been a huge migrant destination — even now it’s hardly the hardest hit nation in Europe’s refugee crisis.
The impulse to preserve Switzerland’s national identity and avoid the pitfalls of other European nations is understandable. But it’s also emblematic of a deep and palpable cultural paranoia, given the realities they’re reacting against.
In trying to preserve ‘Swissness‘, Switzerland’s actually just increasing the chance that Swiss identity will become synonymous with a genteel and self-soothing form of bigotry. And ironically, by trying to avoid problems, they may be creating more: by marginalising those who don’t fit their image of Swiss society, they’re creating just the right conditions for social tension within the nation.