Multiculturalism 'failure' comes as right-wing gains ground

Multiculturalism 'failure' comes as right-wing gains ground

7th March 2011, Comments 7 comments

The "failure" of multiculturalism pronounced by the leaders of France, Britain and Germany comes as far-right parties gain ground across Europe, capitalising on fears of the growing Muslim population.

France's President Nicolas Sarkozy on Thursday, 10 February, became the latest top politician to join the attack on a policy generally understood as meaning that no single culture or set of values should be promoted above any other.

"If you come to France, you accept to melt into a single community, which is the national community, and if you do not want to accept that, you cannot be welcome in France," he said.

"We have been too concerned about the identity of the person who was arriving and not enough about the identity of the country that was receiving him," Sarkozy said in a televised interview.

A week earlier, Britain's Prime Minister Cameron said that "under the doctrine of state multiculturalism, we have encouraged different cultures to live separate lives, apart from each other and the mainstream".

This had resulted in a lack of national identity in Britain which had made some young Muslims turn to extremist ideology, he said.

Dresden : Supporters of the right-extremist NPD party wearing skeleton outfits and carring crosses demonstrate in Dresden, eastern Germany on 13 February 2011

Refugees from Libya wait by latrines in the refugee camp of Choucha in Tunisia

Germany's Merkel, who like her French and British counterparts, is on the centre-right, said in October that efforts towards multiculturalism in her country had "failed, totally."

The comment followed weeks of anguished debate sparked by the huge popularity of a book by a central banker saying that immigrants, in particular Muslims, were making Germany "more stupid."

Jean-Yves Camus, a French academic who studies the far right, said it was ironic that these statements were being made as people in Muslim countries like Tunisia and Egypt were rising up to demand Western-style freedoms.

"At the very moment when the people of the Arab world are aspiring to more democracy... we in Europe are telling people who have chosen to live in our countries that their integration is a problem," he said.

Camus noted that while integration models may vary between EU states, "the common denominator is immigration that comes from outside of Europe and which is Muslim."

Declarations like Sarkozy's are part of a "general trend in Europe towards an increase in very tense discourse on immigration caused by the economic crisis," said sociologist Agathe Voisin, who researches immigration in France and Britain.

Analysts say that the crisis is boosting the fortunes of a new generation of far-right political leaders taking root across the continent.

Moscow : Russian nationalist Dmitry Dyomushkin, gestures as he joined a press conference given by the Movement Against Illegal Immigration (DPNI) in Moscow on 16 February 2011

Thousands of tunisians hold banners during a silent demonstration on 5 March 2011

France's Marine Le Pen has just taken the helm of her notorious father's National Front, while in the Netherlands populists last year became the country's third biggest party.
Far-right parties currently are in government in Italy and backing minority cabinets in Denmark and the Netherlands. They also sit in the parliaments of Austria, Bulgaria, Hungary, Latvia, Slovakia and Sweden.

Fear of Muslim immigration is also a major factor in the rise of the far-right, say analysts.

Four in 10 French and German people regard Muslims living in their country as a "threat," according to an IFOP opinion poll published last month France has the largest Muslim population in Europe, estimated at about six million out of a total population of 65 million, originating largely from its former colonies in North and West Africa.

Germany received vast numbers of migrant workers, most of them from Muslim Turkey, from the 1960s. German federal authorities estimate its current Muslim population at up to 4.3 million, out of a total population of 82 million.

Britain has 2.9 million Muslims, mostly of Pakistani or Indian background, among its total population of 62 million, according to figures from US think-tank the Pew Research Centre.

AFP/ Anne-Laure Mondesert/ Expatica

7 Comments To This Article

  • JG posted:

    on 22nd March 2011, 16:34:55 - Reply

    Let the Europeans moan. Ageing population, dwindling resources, lack of significant number of graduates in essential areas like Engineering and Science, compared to chin, india etc...
    Let them complain. Soon not that long in the future we wont be needing them.
  • DiMaria posted:

    on 10th March 2011, 22:50:36 - Reply

    Absolutely. The funniest thing is about Turkey. News in Expatica:
    Two rulings by Turkey's Supreme Court mean that municipalities near the 1600-year-old Mor Gabriel Monastery can legally seize 50 of its hectares. The monastery is the oldest and most important monastery of Turkey's Syrian Orthodox minority.
    While Turkey keenly defends religious freedom for Muslims in Europe and even sends imams to the Netherlands, the CDA argues that, at home, the Turkish government flouts all international agreements regarding religious freedom. The controversy comes a year after the European Council called on Ankara to stop the expropriation of the monastery's lands.

    Where are we going? What other otion we have but to embrace nationalist parties?
  • JB posted:

    on 10th March 2011, 12:53:59 - Reply

    No-one in Europe was ever asked if he / she wanted untold millions of foreigners to flood our countries. In the UK traitors such as Tony Blair/Brown etc ( now David Cameron) encouraged 4million immigrants into Britain, not including the estimated 2million illegal asylum seekers, in the past five years. The far-left ( Communists ) supported this also. A long term One-World government is their untold aim, where everyone is a coffe coloured brown. As PM Blair swore he would ensure Turkish membership of the EU, as does Cameron today, so add another 80million Muslims to Europe's death knell. Gaddafi did say that they will conquer Europe through Muslim breeding, and if allowed to continue it WILL happen. Then when the flag of Islam flies over us it will be far too late to complain! You have been warned, support your nationalist party whenever possible. Say no to an Islamic Europe.
  • J.Khan posted:

    on 9th March 2011, 23:08:37 - Reply

    May be to some extent they are right. The immigrants brought a new life to the europe. They reconstructed europe and made it a power in the last few decades. Creating an anti immigration/anti islam phoebia may be in the interest of politician to stay in power for a few more years but not in the interests of the states for longer. If they shut the doors to immigrants and they must expect a shut of the door at the other end, on whose natural resources, strategic locations, they are surviving. The age of slavery is long gone. No is the age for an eye for an eye.
    But on the other hand, what is the biggest threat to the muslim world from the west ? Through out history, west exported slavery, poverty, hunger, supported dictators and corrupt politicians, exploited its natural resources, sabotage its new democracies for economic purposes, and never hesitated to kill millions and millions of muslims in the recent history in the name of freedom and democracy.
  • DiMaria posted:

    on 9th March 2011, 21:04:21 - Reply

    gaddafi -the one that claims to be fighting against islamists - said it clearly some time ago: 'We'll conquer Europe through the bellies of our women'. Look at France: 10% of the population and growing. God save us!
  • Norbert Van Acker posted:

    on 9th March 2011, 20:14:15 - Reply

    Though it is not bad that people of different origin or beliefs do live together, governments should be aware of the inherent problems multiple cultures bring about and take legal actions to regulate the number of people from foreign origin or belief.

    Our democratic way of living together can easily be destroyed if the election numbers are wrong. If 30 or 40% of people in a population are of foreign origin, they will take their democratic rights, and start interfering in the political process one way or another.

    Even in a country as Belgium, Dutch and French speaking people do not mingle. French speaking aristocrats did cut us away from “The Netherlands” in 1830, - they didn’t like the Dutch culture - and since then the majority of French speaking Belgians refuse to learn Dutch. The French speakers, moreover, have the divine right - by birth - to impose their culture on everybody living in Belgium. Thus, the actual Belgian problem is a multicultural one too. The Belgian aristocracy and bourgeoisie are to blame for 180 years of cultural colonisation.
  • ron posted:

    on 9th March 2011, 15:55:23 - Reply

    Muslims do not belong in Europe...NOT NOW, NOT EVER !

    They must be removed from the continent, and take their Halal and Sharia with them.

    Except for multi-cultural Jackasses, Europeans never wanted nor needed Muslims and their Islamic Garbage !