Dutch government defends restraint of mentally disabled
The Dutch government on Thursday defended the physical restraint of mentally disabled patients in the midst of a public outcry over a teenager reportedly harnessed to a wall daily since 2007.
"It may be that some people are so ill that it is necessary to protect them against themselves," deputy health minister Marlies Veldhuijzen van Zanten-Hyllner told journalists after visiting the young man at an institution in Ermelo in the central Netherlands.
"I take my leave of Brandon and his carers with my mind at ease," she said after meeting the 18-year-old identified in the media only by his first name, and who hears a voice telling him to do bad things, according to the minister.
Brandon's story was broadcast into Dutch living rooms this week with images of him chained in a harness to one of the four walls of his room, a practice it said was repeated daily for the last three years.
The harness is around his body, leaving his hands and feet free and allowing him to move up to about a metre from the wall.
The Christian public broadcaster Evangelische Omroep showed the footage taken by an employee of the institution and said Brandon had not seen the outside of the institution for three years.
"My son lives like a caged animal," the boy's mother told the broadcaster. "He feels like a dog on a rope. It hurts to see him like this."
Despite protests by MPs in parliament and widespread condemnation in the media, the deputy minister said on Thursday she was happy with the "professionalism" of the institution.
"It is easier to judge from outside," the Dutch news agency ANP quoted Veldhuizen van Zanten-Hyllner as saying. "I don't think that there are institutions that have better methods than here."
The deputy minister said in a letter to parliament on Wednesday there were about 40 other patients living in similar circumstances to those of Brandon.
© 2011 AFP