China's opening ceremony impossible in the West

20th August 2008, Comments 1 comment

Director Zhang Yimou said labour unions and regulations would have made it impossible for western countries to organise such a large scale performance for the Olympics.

20 August 2008

BEIJING - China's spectacular opening ceremony could not have been achieved in the West because labour unions and regulations would have got in the way, director Zhang Yimou told a Chinese newspaper recently.

In an interview with Southern Weekend, Zhang, who is top director of the Olympics' opening and closing ceremonies, said China is number one when it comes to holding mass performances in which thousands perform synchronised, highly choreographed movements.

"I think other than North Korea (and China), no other country can achieve this in the world," Zhang said.

Zhang said he managed to get more than 15,000 people to perform various dances and moves at the National Stadium, or "Bird's Nest" through a lot of hard training and strict disciple - something he doubts he could accomplish in Western countries.

"Foreigners admire this. This is the Chinese spirit. We can make our human performance reach such a level, through hard and smart work. This is something many foreigners cannot achieve," said Zhang.

Getting foreign performers to do the same would be very difficult, Zhang said.

"I have conducted operas in the West. It was so troublesome. They only work four and a half days each week. Everyday there are two coffee breaks and no overtime work at all. There cannot be any discomfort, because of human rights. This can really worry me to death," said Zhang.

"Wow, one week, I thought I should already have rehearsed it (the programme) very smoothly, but they could not even stand in straight lines. You could not criticise them either. They all belong to some organisations. They have all kinds of institutions, unions."

China does not have independent workers' unions and Chinese performers can withstand discomfort, Zhang said.

"We can work very hard, can withstand lots of bitterness. We can achieve in one week what they can achieve in two months," Zhang said.

Almost one third of the world's population - a little over 2 billion - watched the opening ceremony of the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games, according to the global market research company Nielsen on Thursday.

The show was widely perceived as being spectacular, but controversy broke out later after a Chinese agency revealed that the little girl who sang the Hymn to the Motherland during the ceremony, was miming because the real singer was not considered pretty enough to appear on stage.

It was also revealed later that the 900 soldiers had to wear incontinence pads because they had to wait in the stadium for seven hours without a toilet break before their performance.

The hundreds of white uniformed girls who opened umbrellas with smiley faces also had to practice the simple move of opening an umbrella 1,000 times, one of them told Chinese media.

[dpa / Expatica]

What are your views on the Olympic Games? Will you be supporting your country or host country? Click here to take part in a survey especially conducted by Expatica and Ruigrok | NetPanel.

1 Comment To This Article

  • Dotty posted:

    on 21st August 2008, 10:39:08 - Reply

    I fully agree with his comments. Chinese and most asians have higher expectations for perfections and less tolerance for failures. The western counterparts have higher acceptance and allowances for failures. This is very prevalence even from the young age in school.
    These are just pros and cons to their different cultures.