blogs
For the love of bureaucracy 26/02/2008 00:00
American expat Eric Asp is not sure if he is impressed or revolted by the sheer intricacies of Dutch bureaucracy he finds himself inadvertently bound up in after simply asking for permission to have his six-year-old son miss the last seven weeks of kindergarten.
I had a meeting at ten this morning with a city official to process our family's request for our son to miss the last seven weeks of kindergarten, in order to accommodate for an employer-required three-month "home service leave" (a.k.a. furlough) that cannot but result in some school being missed, since the Dutch summer vacation is only six weeks long. The job title of the man with whom I met was leerplichtambtenaar, which -- I am not making this up -- can be very literally translated as "compulsory education bureaucrat."
Truthfully, I was expecting a fifteen-minute ‘rubber stamp’ type meeting -- more or less automatically approving our request (since the teachers and administrators at Elliot's school haven't expressed any concern about our plans, and since -- seriously -- we're talking about a six-year-old missing a seven-week stretch of kindergarten!).
The Compulsory Education Bureaucrat had really done his homework before heading into our meeting. He had apparently already spoken, with the administration at Elliot's school (and I can't remember for sure, but I think he even said that he had talked with Elliot's kindergarten teacher herself) and gotten a full report of Elliot's educational development and even our family's general involvement in the school.
He had researched the website for Great Commission Ministries (my employer) and printed out mission statements and descriptions of the organisation's world-wide activity. And as he fetched cappuchinos for us to enjoy while we talked, I realised that our meeting was to be no fifteen-minute rubber stamping. In fact, it was an hour-and-a-half of discussion. The tone of the discussion was very pleasant, even neighbourly, but the questions were deep, sincere, and probing:
What exactly is your function within the organisation?
Tell me more about your "home groups." What is the purpose of "home groups" and your function in them?
How did you become a Christian?
So would you say that you feel "called" to work in the Netherlands?
Why does GCM require a three-month "home service leave?" Don't they realise that it conflicts with Dutch educational law?
What exactly will you be doing while you're on your "home service leave?"
How is it exactly that your work in the Netherlands is financially supported?
Is it really necessary that your wife and children come along with you for your home service leave? Couldn't they just join you for the six weeks of the Dutch summer vacation in July and August?
I got the sense that the Compulsory Education Bureaucrat was genuinely trying to understand and not simply antagonise me. At certain moments, I even felt a sense of personal interest in who I am and what I do (he confessed that he was brought up in a Christian home). I could completely understand that the leerplichtambtenaar had been commissioned by the government to do a certain job, to enforce a certain set of laws, and to conscientiously evaluate each case that came across his desk.
Yet I was simultaneously astonished by the amount of time, energy, and money that the Dutch government puts into the investigation of a single family's request for seven weeks of absence from school. I was frustrated that the Dutch philosophy of education stresses the importance of paid professionals so much more than the importance of parents. And I was shocked to leave the office of the ‘compulsory education bureaucrat’ with a considerable stack of homework to be completed before the application for an extended leave of absence will be further processed.
I have to arrange for professional translation of GCM employment policies (as they relate to home service leave). I have to fill out a detailed schedule of my travel plans for the summer (preferably with visual aids, i.e. maps, to help contextualise and inform of the necessity of an extended period of leave). I have to write out a detailed education plan for Elliot, explaining how we will continue to prioritise our son's education while missing school in the Netherlands. I have to provide extra employment documents (my work contract, the mission statement of GCM, a letter from GCM headquarters explaining the intent of a home service leave and the necessity of including the entire family for the entire duration of the home service leave) -- all professionally translated into Dutch by an government-sanctioned translation business. It's crazy!
But I'm working on it. I thought it was interesting today, to map out our travel plans for this summer and compare the scope of American geography to that of the Netherlands (I've displayed the results of this work here on the right, for your amusement). I don't even bother to mark out the differences between Peoria and Chicago, Minneapolis and Alexandria, because the scope of American geography is so much greater than that of the Netherlands (even though the journey between cities like these, even within the same state, would be equal to the distance between two cities in the Netherlands that would be considered "very far apart").
You gotta love the culture clashes, don't you?
26 February 2008
Eric Asp is an American videographer/writer/pastor living in Amsterdam, together with his wife and three children. His casual and critical observations on life, love, and faith can be found on-line at www.ericasp.com.
[Copyright Eric Asp 2008]
7 reactions to this article
Sudhir posted: 26-02-2008 | 5:37 PM
very interesting !!! i am also planning to take my kid for longer vacation , but after hearing this, i am in doubt.
American Guy posted: 27-02-2008 | 7:17 PM
I ignored the rules and did as I please, but this was 20 years ago and the Government was much more understanding of Americans back then. Lets be honest, a child missing education in kindergarden by missing 7 weeks, stupid if you ask me.
BTW my children both went to universities here in spite of their missing weeks of school, my daughter when tested was the 10th highest Physics score in the country for a girl, in her last year of high school.
The Dutch Government just love to stick their nose in everyones business, and then tell them how to live, it makes the Govt. feel needed. What a joke.
Totally posted: 27-02-2008 | 7:32 PM
Totally nuts.
John posted: 27-02-2008 | 9:09 PM
Incredible. As in "I can't believe this". But then again, I guess I can, given my experiences here.
What are they going to do if you just ignore them and go? Kick him out of kindergarten? Seriously.
KL posted: 28-02-2008 | 8:17 AM
Quite hypocritical really when the current news tells us there are not enough teachers to go around in Holland, and chidlren are made to go to school even when there is no teacher available for them.
I'm pleased Holland seems to be taking education seriously, but we all know the reality is quite different and this seems to be yet another of the Dutch red-tape items which is all hot-air. I also find it quite surprising that indeed, the parents are not allowed to make this decision on behalf of their family/child. I find it reasonable to have the school/teacher involved in the process (making sure they know, checking the child will not miss too much, taking 'homework' if the teacher thinks it appropriate) but come on - spending our tax money on all of this - where is the balance?!?!
dusgusted posted: 29-02-2008 | 8:27 PM
in my experience here, this is not surprising in the least. this country is a joke as it pertains to government, service, quality of goods, etc. people are rude, snobby, arrogant, and generally slow thinking. i would sure like some accounting of this bogus 19% v.a.t. !!!
differing opinion posted: 03-03-2008 | 8:07 AM
Sure, why not just let any kid miss 6 weeks of school for any reason whatsoever? Six weeks of school at the wrong period could be disastrous. A kid could miss long division, an entire subject in history class, or some critical concept in science or language. Expecting to be treated specially because your kid is "only" in kindergarten, you're an american, or you're a pastor is a bit silly if you ask me. I'm glad the Dutch are looking after your kid's education!
Best summer photo: ethnic beauty at T’nalak festival
Expatica reader Ronald de Jong captured this image at the T’nalak festival in the Philippines.
disscussion forum
- International News OBAMA or NOBAMA, by Wild Rose Country 07/09/2008 00:45
- USA Forum Salaries in Amsterdam vs US (large cities), by ouloveit1 07/09/2008 00:08
- Discuss Dutch Culture Using mobile phones when cycling - Fine or not?, by Stonewall 07/09/2008 00:05
- Legal Problems Reapply/extension of zelfstandig work permit, by tamsind 06/09/2008 22:37
- Pets Newfoundlander, by pulguinha 06/09/2008 21:57
archive
word of the day : Aangenaam
meaning : Pleased to meet you
phrase of the day : Hoe gaat het?
meaning : How are you?
- Dear Mr Nauta i am moving to the netherlands to live with my long suffering girlfriend and am curently compiling a CV that will be relavant, could you point me in the rite direction i need to find out what the dutch equivalant of my National Diploma and National Vocational Qualification is. many thanks in advance. sincerely simon Dear Simon, I am not an expert on rating diploma's, but there is an excellent bureau called nuffic.nl that can help you further. My best guess is that if your diploma is a high school degree it can be Voortgezet Wetenschappelijk Onderwijs. If it is university degree: universiteits diploma of bul. If it is in between: hogere beroepsopleiding. But do contact nuffic on this. Good luck! David Nauta www.guapa.org Asked by : Simon Brumby Answered by : Immigration Expert David Nauta
internaxx
| Index | Last | Var.(%) |
|---|---|---|
| BEL 20 | 3002.39 | -2.08 |
| DAX | 6127.44 | -2.42 |
| IBEX 30 | 11139.7 | -2.97 |
| CAC 40 | 4196.66 | -2.49 |
| FTSE 100 | 5240.7 | -2.26 |
| AEX | 389.22 | -2.00 |
| DJIA | 11220.96 | 0.29 |
| Nasdaq | 2255.88 | -0.14 |
| MIB 30 | 28131 | -2.43 |
| TSX Composite | 12816.42 | 0.02 |
| ASX | 4949.5 | -2.01 |
| Hang seng | 19933.28 | -2.24 |
| Straits Times | 2574.21 | -1.97 |
also on expatica
- Share your content! Expatica is looking for readers who want to contribute regularly to our websites.
- Expatica Classifieds Read and publish classified ads quickly, easily, and for free!
- A parents' guide to international education Confused by the options? Here's an introduction to international education in the Netherlands.
- Join the Expatica community Meet, make friends and network with other internationals just like you
- Expatica’s 2008 Expat Survey Expatica is conducting an audience survey to better understand our readers. Take the survey here.
- Renting or buying in the Netherlands? Here is our introduction to the housing market in the Netherlands. Should you rent or buy?
- What is your life like as an “expat”? Share your expat experience as a panel member of the European Expat Panel.























