US not playing fair in trade: French, German industry

11th July 2014, Comments 1 comment

The United States is not playing fairly in its trade with Europe and is deliberately undermining Europe's banking system, the heads of German and French industry said in newspaper interviews Friday.

"It cannot be that America is weakening the European financial system and then buying up a bank here or there," the head of the powerful BDI industry federation Ulrich Grillo said in an interview published both in the German daily FAZ and the French newspaper Les Echos.

He called for a "clear regulation" in the banking sector and accused the US of seeking to "starve" European banks by slapping huge fines on them.

French bank BNP was recently fined nearly $9.0 billion (6.6 billion euros) for violating US sanctions against blacklisted countries including Iran and Sudan.

The US authorities are similarly investigating Germany's second-biggest bank Commerzbank on the same suspicions and the country's biggest lender Deutsche Bank has set aside billions of euros in provisions in case it is fined too.

"From a philosophical point of view, and from the point of view of the way the dollar and the euro are organised, I think there are some real questions which need to be asked, and quickly, to prevent a weakening of the European banking system," said the president of the French Medef federation, Pierre Gattaz.

But the French and German concerns are not solely about the banking system, but wider economic and trade relations as well.

Both Grillo and Gattaz said they take issue with the US tax system, which allows US companies to place money abroad without taxing it. Such a set-up enabled, for example, General Electric to build up substantial financial reserves, with which it was able to finance its bid for the energy business of French group Alstom, beating a rival bid from Siemens of Germany.

BDI chief Grillo said such a system allowed US companies to put 30-40 percent more money on the table.

"That's a very real distortion of competition and it's making life difficult for us," Grillo complained.

He added that he hoped international tax harmonisation would be discussed at a G20 level.


© 2014 AFP

1 Comment To This Article

  • Clive Sampson posted:

    on 12th July 2014, 11:37:14 - Reply

    I agree entirely with Linda Baldwin's comments. US authorities are equally hard on US banks who break the rules.

    However, the other main point in the article regarding the fact that US entities not being taxed by the US on profits made outside of the US and hoarded in tax havens is really a very serious problem for all of us in Europe, and needs to be dealt with one way or another. Obviously US companies of all types, not just banks, are in a position to use these untaxed funds to gain unfair competitive advantage over tax paying firms when it comes to takeovers of European companies. Why should this be allowed? Either we should make them pay European taxes as they earn their profits in Europe or they should pay tax to us in proportion to the bids in which they are successful.

    Clearly, we would be better off if we in Europe got our acts together and stopped them all from avoiding tax in the countries in which they make their profits by outlawing the current practice of allowing them to route funds via countries like Ireland and Luxembourg where they can get away with paying the absolute minimum of tax in the first place.

    The remedy lies in the hands of European governments!!