Sarkozy, Merkel propose 'true eurozone government'
France's Nicolas Sarkozy and Germany's Angela Merkel vowed to give the eurozone bloc a "true economic government" Tuesday but experts said their pledges were not enough to defuse the debt crisis.
Speaking after talks in Paris, Europe's power couple said they would propose an EU-wide tax on financial transactions and seek to create a eurozone governing body headed by European Union president Herman van Rompuy.
"We're heading towards a strengthened economic integration of the eurozone," Sarkozy said after just over two hours of talks with Merkel.
But the pair disappointed many by not backing the idea of issuing "eurobonds" to pool the debts of the 17 eurozone members and by insisting the bloc's existing 440-billion-euro ($634 billion) bail-out fund is "sufficient".
Instead, the leaders said member states would be held to a tougher fiscal standard and new cross-border controls put in place.
Sarkozy told reporters at the Elysee Palace that all eurozone members should adopt laws by the middle of next year committing their governments to balanced budgets, on the model of Germany's widely admired constitution.
The summit had been keenly awaited by Europe's jittery financial markets, which dipped sharply during the day on reports that it would not produce much of substance.
In a signal of how markets might react, US stocks fell after the summit, snapping a three-session winning streak.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped 77.20 points (0.67 percent) to 11,405.70 in closing trade, while the broad-market S&P 500 fell 11.77 points (0.98 percent) to 1,192.72 and the tech-rich Nasdaq Composite slumped 31.75 points (1.24 percent) to 2,523.45.
European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso hailed the agreement, saying the plans "represent an important political contribution by the leaders of the two largest euro area economies."
But the pair's announcement was scorned by some economists, who decried the decision not to consider eurobonds nor to beef up the stability fund -- which most judge insufficient to bail out a country the size of Italy or Spain, seen as the next countries most at risk of needing help.
"The Franco-German meeting has not produced anything new or useful," said Sony Kapoor of the economic policy think tank Re-Define. "If this is all they had to say, what was the point of having this meeting?
"I fail to see how a balanced budget amendment... or even a financial transaction tax will tackle the euro crisis, help stimulate growth or even strengthen the weak EU banking system," he said.
At the same time, Kapoor conceded that the "proposed eurozone council can be seen as a step in the direction of more fiscal integration opening up the path to eurobonds" but as such it would not tackle the immediate problems.
A note to investors from bankers VTB Capital agreed, saying: "Investors might be left wondering what was the point of this meeting.
"Plenty of well-intentioned rhetoric as usual and more austerity and closer fiscal surveillance overseen by the Euro Council but no silver bullet to resolve the debt and banking crisis," it said.
Rene Defossez, a bond strategist at Natixis, said "the only thing that could defuse the crisis is creating a market for eurobonds... then the market would think twice about attacking a country."
But the leaders put a brave face on the proposals.
"I am confident in the economic prospects of the eurozone and of the world," said Sarkozy, who last week broke off a holiday to plan austerity measures and quash rumours France was to lose its triple-A credit rating.
"I'm not at all pessimistic about growth prospects," Merkel added.
France's growth is stagnant and earlier in the day Berlin announced that German growth was down sharply in the second quarter. Brussels said eurozone growth as a whole had slowed to a measly 0.2 percent.
"The German and French finance ministers will put a joint proposition for a tax on financial transactions on the table of European institutions from next month, September," Sarkozy said.
The French leader repeated his pledge to reduce France's public deficit to under three percent of GDP -- the theoretical EU maximum -- by 2013, and said other eurozone members should adopt the so-called "Golden Rule".
This would take the form of a law, like the one he is in the course of pushing through in France, that would force governments to adopt a public strategy of returning to balanced budgets within a limited timeframe.
Merkel said issuing eurobonds would not be helpful "today" and Sarkozy said such an instrument would put Europe's stronger economies "in grave danger" and would only be possible at the "end of a process of integration".
© 2011 AFP