France's Vivendi favours Numericable in telecoms bidding war
French conglomerate Vivendi said Friday it was entering exclusive talks with Numericable to sell the cable operator its telecoms unit SFR, shrugging aside France's industrial renewal minister's attempt at scuppering a deal between the two.
The announcement came just hours after Arnaud Montebourg took Numericable to task over its multi-billion-euro offer for SFR, challenging the company and its billionaire chairman over their holdings in tax havens and their ability to pay for the deal.
Numericable through its parent company Altice had offered 10.9 billion euros ($15.2 billion) and a 32 percent stake in the new merged company for Vivendi's SFR, currently France's second-largest mobile network.
But it emerged that the cable operator had sweetened the offer since, as Vivendi said Friday it has "decided to enter into exclusive negotiations with Altice for a period of three weeks" on the basis of an offer which includes a payment of 11.75 billion euros and a 32 percent stake in the new entity.
Numericable was facing competition from construction and telecoms group Bouygues which has offered 11.3 billion euros and 43 percent of the new company, valuing SFR at 15.5 billion euros.
Vivendi said a merger with Numericable "is the most pertinent for shareholders and employees of the group and which offers the best security of execution."
The news sent Numericable shares soaring 20.63 percent to 31.85 euros, far outperforming the overall market which was down 1.32 percent.
Hours before the group announced its choice, Montebourg had sought to cast doubt on Numericable's offer.
- Minister lambasts cable firm -
"The managers of Vivendi have decided to sell SFR to Numericable at all costs," the minister said.
The choice "poses a certain number of problems and questions", among which is Altice's ability to foot the bill, and its holdings in Luxembourg as well as the tax status of its chairman Patrick Drahi, he said.
"There is a tax problem because Numericable has a holding in Luxembourg, the company is listed on the Amsterdam stock market, his personal holding is in Guernsey in a tax paradise of Her Majesty the Queen of England, and he himself is a Swiss resident."
"Mr Drahi will have to repatriate all of his possessions and assets to Paris, to France," the minister told Europe 1 radio.
"Numericable is a small company compared to SFR," he added, saying that "it's a company of five billion that is taking on debt of 10 billion to buy something that it bigger than itself".
"What we fear is over-indebtedness," he said.
But Altice said Numericable is listed in France where it is also headquartered. Any new SFR-Numericable entity would likewise be based here.
The French government, which is struggling to bring down its public deficit, has been bluntly critical of citizens who keep their assets in tax havens like Switzerland, Luxembourg or Guernsey.
The possible sale of SFR to Bouygues had been the favourite of many analysts as it would have resulted in the number of mobile networks dropping to three, likely ending the fierce price wars that had eroded profits and slowed investment in next generation services.
While consumer groups expressed concern, regulators had indicated such a merger might be approved after Bouygues announced plans to offload its current network to the fourth operator, which is struggling to build its own.
© 2014 AFP