France bans naming teachers on school-rating website

4th March 2008, Comments 0 comments

French court on Monday ordered a website to stop naming teachers, after the country's educational establishment denounced it as "public lynching".

   PARIS, March 4, 2008  - A French court on Monday ordered a website
that allows pupils to rate their schools to stop naming teachers, after the
country's educational establishment denounced it as "public lynching".
   The website,, which opened late January based on similar
sites that have existed for years in Britain, the United States and many other
countries around the world, proved wildly popular with students and parents.
   In just four weeks they gave marks out of 20 to 50,000 of their teachers
nad judged whether they were "interesting," "available," "respected," or
   Judgments, made anonymously, were on the whole favourable, with an average
rating of 14.
   But teachers, already smarting after a suggestion by President Nicolas
Sarkozy that they might face performance reviews to which students could
contribute, were incensed.
   A group of teachers and several teachers' union asked a Paris court to
decide whether the site broke privacy laws by publishing teachers' names and
ratings and whether it breached their right to be judged only by superiors.
   On Monday, the court ordered the site to stop using teachers' names both on
the general site and in its discussion forums and said it would impose a fine
of 1,000 euros per day for each day it failed to implement the judgment.
   "The exercise of freedom of information and of expression has as limits
that it does not damage teaching activities," it said.
   The court however allowed the site to continue rating schools.
   Education Minister Xavier Darcos said he had "noted with satisfaction" the
ruling and reiterated his "support for teachers whose difficult job should not
be the object of anonymous attacks on the internet."
   Stephane Cola, the site's founder, said he would appeal the ruling, which
he said was "contrary to the evolution of the Internet."
   The ruling could lead to similar sites to rate French teachers being
launched abroad, outside the control of French legal authorities, he said. 
   "We hope that the decision of the appeal court will conform more to what is
going on everywhere else outside of France, particularly in Germany," said
   Since sites such as were launched in the early years
of this century, many teachers and teaching unions in countries across the
globe have been enraged by students' comments on their performance.
   Many schools blocked access to these websites from computers on their
premises but were unable to have the sites shut down.
   Last year a German court, hearing a case taken by a teacher against a
rating site, ruled that teachers could be rated online by their pupils.
   It said the ratings, so long as they were not defamatory, were allowable
under the principles of freedom of expression and that publishing a teacher's
name was acceptable because it could easily be found on the school's website.
   Ian Brown of the Universtiy of Oxford's Internet Institute told AFP by
telephone that "we'll see cases higher up the European legal system to see
whether the German decision or the French one will be upheld."
   He also said that the French ruling was likely to lead to teacher rating
sites being set up outside of French legal jurisdiction.  
   The CNIL, France's independent authority charged with ensuring that data
privacy law is applied, is due to give its verdict on the
website on Thursday.


0 Comments To This Article