topics
tools
editor's choice

State and private schools in Spain

Festivals in Spain 2011

Should our kids go native too?

Childcare in Spain

Moving to Barcelona with children

Expatica countries
Index Last Var.(%)
BEL 20 2238.23 -1.43
DAX 6682.76 -1.56
IBEX 30 8781.1 -1.36
CAC 40 3381.08 -1.27
FTSE 100 5850.82 -0.76
AEX 320.23 -1.50
DJIA 12781.93 -0.84
Nasdaq 2905.71 -0.74
FTSE MIB 16421.79 -1.39
TSX Composite 12342.04 -1.25
ASX 4322.6 -0.79
Hang seng 20783.86 -1.08
Straits Times 2960 -0.71
ISEQ 20 501.74 -0.39
You are here: Home Life in Lifestyle Spain’s celebrities and paparazzi head for war

Lifestyle

archive
Enlarge font Decrease font Text size


26/05/2008Spain’s celebrities and paparazzi head for war

Spain’s celebrities and paparazzi head for war The paparazzi may have won in a battle to pry into the life of the princess’ sister, but the fight is far from over.

MADRID - The first battle may have been lost, but the war between Spain's celebrities and the paparazzi is probably only just beginning.

When a court in Toledo ruled against a request by Telma Ortiz two weeks ago, the younger sister of the princess of Asturias, for an injunction banning the media from taking or using her image, you could almost hear the groans of dismay from harassed celebrities and quasi-celebrities across the country.

The rich, the famous and anyone else who by fortune or misfortune has become a magnet for gossip-hungry TV talk shows and glamour magazines see the failure of Ortiz's case as a missed opportunity to set a legal precedent that would help protect their rights to privacy.

The media, in contrast, have been left none the wiser in a long-running debate that pits an individual's right to privacy against freedom of the press. They still do not know, for example, exactly how far they can go to hunt down a celebrity.

Is it fair or even legal for photographers and film crews to camp outside a celebrity's home and follow their every move? Who should be considered famous, and therefore fair game? And what exactly should be considered news - a new love affair, for example, or a trip to the supermarket?

The problem is that Ortiz's request for an injunction was rejected on mostly technical grounds. The judge found fault with the form in which the case had been presented, while delving only briefly into the substance of the issue.

"It's a shame that this didn't go through to the end," says Jaime Tapia, the spokesperson for a progressive association of magistrates known as Judges for Democracy. "There are cases of abuse as we all know, situations of harassment of certain people that have to be stopped. But the plaintiffs needed to explain their aim and their reasons better. They still have the chance to do that...," he adds.

In seeking an injunction - an unprecedented action - Ortiz and her fiancé Enrique Martín Llop were attempting to obtain a ruling based on what the media might do, not what they had already done.

The couple therefore now has the possibility of attempting to rein in the media through the more usual channel of suing any newspapers, websites or TV stations that they think they can prove have already invaded their privacy.

"Telma Ortiz should have invoked not only the issue of who has the right to use her image, but also how her privacy is affected, because that is what's really at stake," Tapia notes. "Nonetheless, the basic arguments make sense."

But with Ortiz's case over - at a cost to her of EUR 50,000 in court expenses - those arguments may well be stirring debate for some time to come.

text by El Pais / M. C. Belaza / A. E. / Expatica
photos by Google


0 reactions to this article

Be the first person to add a comment

General rating: Not rated yet

Rate article:    Add my rating


0 reactions to this article

Be the first person to add a comment
Life in essentials
Life in expert Q&A
ask your question
Life in A-Z listings
find the business you need
Discussion Forums

English in Spain

Public (free) primary schools in Barcelona + surrounding areas.

Jobs in Spain

IFAs / FSIs / Country Managers / Confidential Introducers

Community Noticeboard Spain

Barcelona-stay updated!

Housing in Spain

Sitges, Barcelona - 5 Bedroom Villa € 1,150,000 For Sale

Jobs in Spain

“Silicon Valley Comes to Barcelona”, 24th Feb 2012

participate in the forums

Inside Expatica
Editor's Guide: Getting Started in Spain

Editor's Guide: Getting Started in Spain

Expatica's Getting Started section will provide practical information on how you can open a bank account, exchange your driving licence, improve your Spanish, and more.

Groups and Clubs in Madrid

Groups and Clubs in Madrid

Here's a guide to an extensive list of groups and clubs in Madrid for expats, from sports groups to social and family gatherings.

Groups and Clubs around Spain

Groups and Clubs around Spain

A brief introduction to our Tax section for Spain, from help with inheritance tax to accounting advice.

Groups and Clubs in Barcelona

Groups and Clubs in Barcelona

Here's a short introduction to our Banking section for those living in Spain, from what to ask the experts to opening a Spanish bank account.