topics
tools
Expatica countries
editor's choice

Expatica readers offer tips for using social media for business

Why renting in Germany is more than just an apartment search

Learning German: Passing the critical stage

O’zapft is! German Festivals in 2011

Public holidays in Germany in 2011

Index Last Var.(%)
BEL 20 2246.14 -1.08
DAX 6727.22 -0.91
IBEX 30 8829.1 -0.82
CAC 40 3400.19 -0.72
FTSE 100 5876.05 -0.33
AEX 322.46 -0.82
DJIA 12890.46 0.05
Nasdaq 2927.23 0.39
FTSE MIB 16577.49 -0.46
TSX Composite 12497.94 -0.18
ASX 4322.6 -0.79
Hang seng 20783.86 -1.08
Straits Times 2960 -0.71
ISEQ 20 502.12 -0.32
You are here: Home Life in Blogs & photos Editor’s diary: The euro by stealth?
Enlarge font Decrease font Text size


27/05/2008Editor’s diary: The euro by stealth?

Editor’s diary: The euro by stealth? Expatica’s guest editor Dominic Hinde sounds off over Britain’s refusal to adopt the euro.

I try not to express an opinion on things I don't know much about, economics being one of them, but one thing that has been getting on my nerves for a while is the stubborn refusal of the UK to join the eurozone, exacerbated by the increasingly flimsy pound.
 
We have a tendency to view Europe as something we can use externally, taking what we want without getting to involved. As a result, we were prepared to let the French and Germans go along with their crazy idea as long as we didn't have to do anything beyond get used to some different coins on our holidays.
 
Generally speaking, economists don't seem to laugh much except. Still, those who advocated a single currency for Europe must now feel some kind of positive emotion stirring within. In Britain, Gordon Brown takes a lot of unfair criticism (he is morally at least a far better man than Tony Blair and more down to earth than his conservative rival, if sometimes misguided). Yet his biggest mistake always has been his reluctance to take the UK into the eurozone.
 
It would do us good as a nation to adopt the euro, making Britain realise that we no longer rule the world as we once did, a final step in decolonialisation as it were. The difference in currency is another barrier in the 'us and them' mentality pervasive in the UK. When the EU members decided to set the admirable target of its citizens being fluent in at least one other language of the member states, the UK proceeded to remove foreign languages from schools as a compulsory subject. That is counterintuitive to say the least and feels a bit like a naughty child doing the opposite to what they are told despite knowing it's stupid.
 
In Scotland, where the banks issue their own money under license, one has produced a new 20-pound note, which looks suspiciously like a euro note. One of my good friends, who has quite traditional opinions on the sovereignty of the UK, genuinely believes that this is in fact a plot to introduce the euro without the population noticing. He says there will come a point where the notes look the same and the currency is worth the same and it'll be too late, which is exactly my argument.
 
As the pound and the euro seem set to have more or less equal value in the near future, those who used to hide behind 'economic' arguments are now being forced to either admit that they are in fact wet-eyed traditionalists or concede that the time might be right. People express worries over who controls the currency, yet the Bank of England is already independent of the British government. Added to that, I am actually much more comfortable with the idea of a group of efficient Germans controlling our monetary policy than some stuffy old men in London.
 
It is frustrating to step off the train in Brussels with a wallet full of unusable British currency. In shops, people snigger because you spend ages rifling through the coins in your hand to find the right one instead of recognising them by weight and shape without a second glance.
 
Most people in Britain know even less about economics than I do. If you ask people, they seem to oppose the euro without really knowing why (some people still refuse to use the metric system, too). What Britain needs to do is either give its people a concrete reason not to be in the euro club or get on with it.
 
 Copyright Expatica 2008


3 reactions to this article

John posted: 2008-05-28 09:24:58

Quite apart from all the other reasons why Britain should not enter the eurozone is inflation. I remember when we went decimal - it led to massive inflation as prices were rounded up. My German friends complain of the rise in prices when they gave up the Dmark - I say - I told you so!

Peter Römer posted: 2008-05-28 12:11:37

Actually there where no rise in prices to speak of its just the ignorance of the exchange rate at the time between the D mark and Euro. And that something of this magnetude was happening all at once. Germans like to complain like everyone else when something new is introduced that they are not familiar with.

Darren Peters posted: 2008-05-28 14:57:51

To argue that the Britain should adopt the Euro because the pound is 'flimsy' makes as much sense as arguing that Europe should have joined the pound when the Euro was weak. Or perhaps we should join the Yuan as the Chinese economy is set to boom. Currencies inevitably move against each other.

If anyone in Britain still thinks we Rule the World, I don't think even a change of currency would get through and the general concept of 'bringing Britain down a peg or two' is hardly a good reason for changing to a foreign currency.

The Bank of England is not that independent of the government as evidenced by recent government intervention of Northern Rock. As good or bad as our politicians are at least we can boot them out now and then - something not possible with the so called 'efficient Germans who control the Euro'. Which is after all a simplistic stereotype. Or perhaps we should have the French controlling our lovemaking and Spanish controlling our weather too:) Better still let's have the Belgians dictate our human rights legislation - oops too late...

As for it being frustrating stepping off of a train with the wrong currency and struggling to understand the Euro coins I would have thought the last person to have that problem was the author. And a million plus wonderful Europeans have happily made the move in the other direction and seem to have no issue accepting the pound.

Finally and most seriously, I don't think the author gives the British people enough credit. It might just be that they don't want to join the Euro because, like some crooked criminal fraternity, once you join you will will never ever be allowed to leave.

3 reactions to this article

John posted: 2008-05-28 09:24:58

Quite apart from all the other reasons why Britain should not enter the eurozone is inflation. I remember when we went decimal - it led to massive inflation as prices were rounded up. My German friends complain of the rise in prices when they gave up the Dmark - I say - I told you so!

Peter Römer posted: 2008-05-28 12:11:37

Actually there where no rise in prices to speak of its just the ignorance of the exchange rate at the time between the D mark and Euro. And that something of this magnetude was happening all at once. Germans like to complain like everyone else when something new is introduced that they are not familiar with.

Darren Peters posted: 2008-05-28 14:57:51

To argue that the Britain should adopt the Euro because the pound is 'flimsy' makes as much sense as arguing that Europe should have joined the pound when the Euro was weak. Or perhaps we should join the Yuan as the Chinese economy is set to boom. Currencies inevitably move against each other.

If anyone in Britain still thinks we Rule the World, I don't think even a change of currency would get through and the general concept of 'bringing Britain down a peg or two' is hardly a good reason for changing to a foreign currency.

The Bank of England is not that independent of the government as evidenced by recent government intervention of Northern Rock. As good or bad as our politicians are at least we can boot them out now and then - something not possible with the so called 'efficient Germans who control the Euro'. Which is after all a simplistic stereotype. Or perhaps we should have the French controlling our lovemaking and Spanish controlling our weather too:) Better still let's have the Belgians dictate our human rights legislation - oops too late...

As for it being frustrating stepping off of a train with the wrong currency and struggling to understand the Euro coins I would have thought the last person to have that problem was the author. And a million plus wonderful Europeans have happily made the move in the other direction and seem to have no issue accepting the pound.

Finally and most seriously, I don't think the author gives the British people enough credit. It might just be that they don't want to join the Euro because, like some crooked criminal fraternity, once you join you will will never ever be allowed to leave.

Inside Expatica
The ABCs of the German school system

The ABCs of the German school system

What you need to know about German schools and daycare.

German immigration and residency regulations

German immigration and residency regulations

Want to move to Germany but haven’t figured out the details? Check out Expatica’s overview of the German permit system.

Driving in Berlin: Rules, habits and fines

Driving in Berlin: Rules, habits and fines

In part one of our two part series, we cover the driving culture in Berlin, where to park and buy gas and, most importantly, the laws.

Looking for work in Germany: The in depth version

Looking for work in Germany: The in depth version

Our comprehensive guide includes information on how to find work, recruitment agencies, employment contracts and labour law.