topics
tools
Expatica countries
Index Last Var.(%)
BEL 20 2270.63 -0.42
DAX 6788.8 0.59
IBEX 30 8902.1 0.60
CAC 40 3424.71 0.43
FTSE 100 5895.47 0.33
AEX 325.12 -0.06
DJIA 12890.46 0.05
Nasdaq 2927.23 0.39
FTSE MIB 16653.83 -0.09
TSX Composite 12497.94 -0.18
ASX 4357.1 -0.15
Hang seng 21010.01 -0.04
Straits Times 2981.17 -0.03
ISEQ 20 503.71 0.33
You are here: Home News Belgian News Just how European are you?

Belgian News

archive
Enlarge font Decrease font Text size


28/08/2008Just how European are you?

People continue to fight over what the term really defines.

28 August 2008

Brussels -- What do Kazakhstan, Israel and the northeastern corner of South America have in common?

Some people count them as European.

Kazakhstan, despite being in Central Asia, is a member of the Union of European Football Associations (UEFA). Israel is in both UEFA and the Eurovision Song Contest -- competing in the latter rather more successfully in recent years than, say, France or Britain.

And the South American area of French Guyana is legally a province of France, which makes it officially a part of the European Union.

Of course, critics would say that it takes a lot more than just joining a European organization to count as properly "European."

But the problem with that criticism is there is, in fact, no commonly-agreed definition of "European" to confirm it.

More than linguistics
That is a far more than just a linguistic problem, because for some countries, the question of whether or not they count as European is a vital matter of foreign policy.

Take Turkey, for example. Both the North Atlantic Treaty which created NATO in 1949 and the various treaties which created the European Union, state that "any European state" which follows their rules can join.

But while NATO invited Turkey into the club as long ago as 1952, the EU is still arguing whether it is sufficiently European to join -- with French President Nicolas Sarkozy, for one, saying it is not.

A similar row broke out in July 2003 after Italy's famously unpredictable Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi started his six-month EU presidency by saying that Israel, among others, should join.

Israel does not "fulfill the geographical criteria" for membership, one Brussels official retorted icily.

A geographical sense?
At present, there are three main theories as to how a country's "Europeanness," or lack thereof, should be defined.

Some authorities say that, as in the case of Israel, "European" should be interpreted in a strictly geographical sense to mean "somewhere between the Atlantic and the Ural mountains."

But that argument falls apart as soon as you consider that Turkey, with a small but significant part of its territory in Europe, is still not accepted as European but that French Guyana is.

Others say that "European" is more of a cultural term, a combination of Greek, Latin, Christian and humanist traditions.

That does justify the exclusion of Turkey, with its culture based on Ottoman Islam. But it falls down every time EU and NATO leaders call Albania and Bosnia, with exactly the same heritage, European.

A values definition
A final argument is that "European" means "based on European values" such as democracy, the rule of law and human rights.

They are certainly values which European leaders talk about a lot.

But any map of Europe based on those criteria would look pretty moth-eaten, as it would feature gaps over countries such as Belarus, Russia and even, arguably, EU members Bulgaria and Italy.

In fact, given the lack of expert agreement on what such a popular word really means, the main definition of "European" in diplomatic circles these days seems to be, "someone we want on our side."

And with Europe desperate to make allies in a world of superpower politics, readers from Mumbai to Melbourne should take heart.

Don't worry if nobody has called you European yet: It's probably only a matter of time.

-- Ben Nimmo/Expatica


2 reactions to this article

Avi Marranazo posted: 2008-08-28 16:02:04

For an academic answer to this question, kindly see evolutionary psychologist, Professor Kevin MacDonald's overview of this issue http://www.kevinmacdonald.net/WesternOrigins.htm

In summary, he argues that Western cultures have a unique cultural profile compared to other traditional civilizations:

1. The Catholic Church and Christianity.
2. A tendency toward monogamy.
3. A tendency toward simple family structure based on the nuclear family.
4. A greater tendency for marriage to be companionate and based on mutual affection of the partners.
5. A de-emphasis on extended kinship relationships and its correlative, a relative lack of ethnocentrism.
6. A tendency toward individualism and all of its implications: individual rights against the state, representative government, moral universalism and science

These stand in stark contrast to the Near East (Jews and Muslims), Far East (Confucians) and sub-Sahara Africa, of course.

rltanizaki posted: 2008-08-29 12:12:18

Dear Mr. Ben Nimmon, Islam is not Ottoman; it pre-dates the Ottoman Empire by hundreds of years. And Turkey is definitely European; only Sarkozy and his counterparts in Vienna deny this. Go to Istanbul, Ephesus, Troy and see the truth.

Add a comment

General rating: Not rated yet

Rate article:    Add my rating


2 reactions to this article

Avi Marranazo posted: 2008-08-28 16:02:04

For an academic answer to this question, kindly see evolutionary psychologist, Professor Kevin MacDonald's overview of this issue http://www.kevinmacdonald.net/WesternOrigins.htm

In summary, he argues that Western cultures have a unique cultural profile compared to other traditional civilizations:

1. The Catholic Church and Christianity.
2. A tendency toward monogamy.
3. A tendency toward simple family structure based on the nuclear family.
4. A greater tendency for marriage to be companionate and based on mutual affection of the partners.
5. A de-emphasis on extended kinship relationships and its correlative, a relative lack of ethnocentrism.
6. A tendency toward individualism and all of its implications: individual rights against the state, representative government, moral universalism and science

These stand in stark contrast to the Near East (Jews and Muslims), Far East (Confucians) and sub-Sahara Africa, of course.

rltanizaki posted: 2008-08-29 12:12:18

Dear Mr. Ben Nimmon, Islam is not Ottoman; it pre-dates the Ottoman Empire by hundreds of years. And Turkey is definitely European; only Sarkozy and his counterparts in Vienna deny this. Go to Istanbul, Ephesus, Troy and see the truth.

Add a comment
Discussion Forums

English in Belgium

ascent of language in belgium

Family in Belgium

Question about summer program/camp in Belgium

Healthcare in Belgium

How to find a good Physio and optometrist?

Jobs in Belgium

IFAs / FSIs / Country Managers / Confidential Introducers

Housing in Belgium

Flatmate Wanted as from mid February – SPACIOUS DUPLEX/PENTHOUSE

participate in the forums

Inside Expatica
Looking for work in Belgium

Looking for work in Belgium

This handy guide from Expertise in Labour Mobility includes how to write a CV, application procedure, interview dos and don'ts, Belgian management culture.

Practical, easy-to-use, free and... in English

Practical, easy-to-use, free and... in English

Belgium’s first alternative directory assistance services - available through the shortcode 14-14 - can now be accessed on the internet.

Finding a rental home in Belgium

Finding a rental home in Belgium

Moving to Belgium presents a host of challenges to expats, not least of all finding the right home.

Learning to cope with life abroad

Learning to cope with life abroad

The psychological effects of global mobility can be physically painful.