topics
tools
editor's choice

Learning with the International Primary Curriculum

Remote training for expatriates

Should our kids go native too?

Pre-school activities in Belgium

How expats are learning the local lingo

Expatica countries
Index Last Var.(%)
BEL 20 2089.49 -2.47
DAX 6285.75 -2.33
IBEX 30 6440.5 -3.31
CAC 40 3003.27 -2.62
FTSE 100 5266.41 -2.53
AEX 289.16 -2.29
DJIA 12496.15 -0.05
Nasdaq 2850.12 0.39
FTSE MIB 12960.87 -3.68
TSX Composite 11564.8 0.99
ASX 4118.8 -1.31
Hang seng 18786.19 -1.33
Straits Times 2780.42 -1.53
ISEQ 20 490.11 -1.66
You are here: Home Leisure Cinema review Cinema: Mamma Mia, it's the Tropa de Elite!
Enlarge font Decrease font Text size


11/09/2008Cinema: Mamma Mia, it's the Tropa de Elite!

Cinema: Mamma Mia, it's the Tropa de Elite! Picturenose's James Drew reviews the blockbuster Mamma Mia! and the semi-fictional account of Rio's Elite Squad.

Mamma Mia!
Hot on the heels of it scooping best musical at the National Movie Awards in London on 8th September, and its star Meryl Streep being named as best actress in the nationwide poll recognizing the year’s blockbuster movies, cinemagoers across Europe are finding out - Mamma Mia! - what all the fuss is about.

Somewhere, over the rainbow, there may be someone who doesn’t know the plot, so here goes – 20-year-old Sophie Sheridan (Amanda Seyfried) is preparing to marry her boyfriend Sky (Dominic Cooper) at her mother's hotel on a Greek island. She seemingly has it all - a carefree life, a loving fiancé, and happy friends, but one thing is missing - a father. To fulfill her lifelong dream of being given away by her Dad at her wedding, she reads the diary of her mother Donna (Meryl Streep) and discovers that she has three possible fathers (Stellan Skarsgård, Pierce Brosnan and Colin Firth) – she secretly invites all three to her wedding, to find an answer before the chapel bells chime…

Taking its cue from the world’s most popular stage comedy musical (which has already earned some 2 billion dollars worldwide), the film features the music of ABBA sung by the cast members (with Brosnan apparently not being Pavarotti’s successor). Leading British theatre director Phyllida Lloyd is in her first feature-film director’s chair, and she would appear to have made a splendid first effort, if box-office receipts and (largely) favourable reviews are anything to go by. Even the customarily curmudgeonly Philip French, writing in The Observer, acknowledges being “bludgeoned into submission by the energy and exuberance and came near to embracing the camp frolics and calculated pseudo-artlessness”. That’s a rave review from old Frenchy…

And the cast’s vocal abilities? Streep has already proven that she can sing (Postcards from the Edge (1990)), but, as for Brosnan’s much-mocked efforts, ABBA singer Benny Andersen hit back at critics in an interview with The Sun newspaper: "Everybody complains that Pierce can't sing and it pisses me off. I think he has a great voice. He couldn't sing Nessun Dorma but neither could I - and I was in ABBA. It's like saying Bob Dylan can't sing. It's just not fair. He has a good voice."



So there you have it – recommendations don’t come much better than that. Get yourself along to see Mamma Mia! – you know that everyone else will…
108 mins.

Tropa de Elite (Elite Squad)
A semi-fictional account of the BOPE (Batalhão de Operações Policiais Especiais), the Special Police Operations Battalion of the Rio de Janeiro military police, director José Padilha film scooped the Golden Bear at the 2008 Berlin Film Festival.

Padilha, who had previously directed the acclaimed hostage documentary Bus 174 (2002) was drawn to the original book Elite da Tropa by sociologist Luiz Eduardo Soares and two former BOPE captains, André Batista and Rodrigo Pimentel, with the script written by Academy Award-nominated screenwriter Bráulio Mantovani.

It is a grimly intense examination of Rio de Janeiro’s notorious favelas, the volatile, dangerous slums to be found at the edge of the city. Set in 1997, the story is an intimate take on the city’s huge web of corruption, with drug traffickers holding near-complete control within the favelas, while the police run their own rackets elsewhere. The elite BOPE combats drug trafficking, and BOPE Captain Nascimento (Wagner Moura) is in crisis: as well as fighting a daily battle in a war zone, Nascimento is looking to train his own replacement so he can get away from the violence and be closer to his wife, who is about to have their first child…

Unfortunately, while exciting and well-intentioned, the film revels in the police violence and corruption that it purports to be condemning. The narration by Nascimento character (Wagner Moura) is a touch oppressive, while the film seems clinically removed from its material. Nascimento seems little more than a passive observer at times and, as the story cuts between the violence in the favelas to police rookie Matias (Andre Ramiro) bouncing off lighter-skinned intellectuals, the alleged realities of how people are divided along racial and economic lines seem patronizing.
118 mins.

James Drew

Please check local listings before travelling. For more reviews, check out  www.picturenose.com

'Expatica's weekly cinema-review section is brought to you in collaboration with Picturenose.com'  

About our reviewers : Putting you in the picture 

Expatica 2008



0 reactions to this article

0 reactions to this article

Inside Expatica
Looking for work in Belgium

Looking for work in Belgium

This handy guide from Expertise in Labour Mobility includes how to write a CV, application procedure, interview dos and don'ts, Belgian management culture.

Practical, easy-to-use, free and... in English

Practical, easy-to-use, free and... in English

Belgium’s first alternative directory assistance services - available through the shortcode 14-14 - can now be accessed on the internet.

Finding a rental home in Belgium

Finding a rental home in Belgium

Moving to Belgium presents a host of challenges to expats, not least of all finding the right home.

Learning to cope with life abroad

Learning to cope with life abroad

The psychological effects of global mobility can be physically painful.